Misguided Mansion tax is the Blunt instrument of envy

The threat of a misguided mansion tax on homes over a certain value remains part of an ill conceived plan to satisfy a floating vote perceived to be motivated by envy.

It is a clumsy proposal. It is dependant on an arbitrary value that bears no relation to the ability of the home owner to pay it. A single elderly widow on minimum earnings will be asked to pay this tax, if her home happens to be valued in excess of a certain amount.

Like Stamp Duty Land Tax this will be a tax on those living in the South East of the country, where most such ‘mansions’ exist. But these ‘mansions’ are not what we all think of as mansions, they are all those houses valued at more than £2m. So in Fulham a two bedroom flat could be classed as a Mansion.

This iniquitous proposal ignores the fact that many larger homes accommodate adult offspring unable to afford a home of their own and if under 25, unable to obtain housing benefit. They may also accommodate staff or lodgers enjoying low housing costs without the need for state subsidy, or they may be the refuge of the single elderly wishing to spend their final years with their family. These homes accommodate more than one household. They are not the residences of the rich.   

There are those who suggest that a moderate tax on wealth would have little effect. Why, we hear them say, is it any different from Council tax? The council tax levied by local authorities is paid for services. Mansion tax is just that, an additional tax levied against the value of a principal private residence on the purely arbitrary basis of the value ascribed to it. It is a wealth tax that has no regard to income whatever.

It is a tax on aspiration that will see successful home buyers choosing to buy their luxury homes in the United States or Dubai rather than UK. These are countries where success is encouraged and rewarded by an ability to buy a super home without envy and the imposition of annual taxes on houses over arbitrary values.

It is a tax that will distort housing markets. With the lower end markets receiving the stimulus of help to buy, upper end is to be heavily taxed with the current 7% SDLT on transactions and an annual tax in addition. The economic benefits of house building apply to all housing markets. Material supply chains and specialist sub contractors for high end housing are just as important as those for affordable housing and can help to continue the momentum that is gaining ground in housing.

Housing markets are moving, and with them will be an economic recovery based on a greater consumer demand for associated goods and services.  Envy has no part in this recovery.

Latest Blogs

Who may hold the ultimate title? Don't just take our word for it, here is what one of our customers has to say Now it's time to deliver on the promise - More new homes Stamp Duty changes create a boom in self-build in Kent Self Build to Save Tax on Your New Home Denis Minns asks - Will Buy to Let attract another new tax? Urbanisation and globalisation are driving today's labour market Misguided Mansion tax is the Blunt instrument of envy What is the solution to housing affordability? Is shared ownership the answer to housing affordability? Town and Country planning associated publish their analysis of UK 2011 Census Bungalows Is it time to slacken the grey belt? With a chronic housing shortage should we make room for Micro homes? Are private house sale websites now the way to sell your home ? Self Build and save money House Building Boom Housing Markets better facilitate renting rather than ownership. How do we swing the balance back toward ownership? Housing is increasingly being seen as a growth driver for the economy The Government is sure it wishes to see more new houses built but seems far less sure how this is to be done ''They who now will bless the poor, shall yourselves find blessing.'' Carol - Good King Wenceslas Housing markets in United States have turned the corner. Housing starts have increased and there are signs too of rising house prices The Government has implemented a number of measures to increase House Building and getting Housing markets moving. Denis Minns offers House Buyers a Chance to Choose House building has become an expensive game of chance with less players willing to take the risk Am I a man more planned against than planning Denis Minns, Managing Director of DBS Homes wants to give credit where it is due Today, the green vision of Eco towns is stuck in the 'Brown' legacy of environmental red tape and regulation. 'Keen to be green'

Latest News

The ultimate bespoke home for purchaser Offset Stamp Duty to Design & Build your dream home DBS Homes' excellent reputation precedes them Birchwood & Sunningdale, Chelsfield Park - Coming Soon Surrey Collection Coming Soon A modern world in a period shell DBS Homes Housing Association - Shepway Today Wisteria in the Weald Purchasers find that quality shines through DBS Homes - Always thinking about tomorrow Choose an enviously green lifestyle in a DBS home Pinecroft - advertorial Oakwood, Otford - advertorial Stylish design & just 17 minutes from the city

© DBS Sevenaoks Limited 2017    
tel: 01732 240555       email: